McNairy County, TennesseeHistory Archives

Newspaper clipping

False Charges Against Sheriff Deouties Continuation

This is the text of the clipping below, read from the picture by computer so it can be read aloud and searched. Old newsprint reads imperfectly, so some words may be wrong. Tell us if you spot one.

Newspaper clipping: False Charges Against Sheriff Deouties Continuation. Its text follows below.

Text of the clipping

gate because (Tava Lawson) started . spreading lies,” Sheriff Lee said.

Calling Lawson’s motives unclear, Sheriff Lee said: “I assume (Lawson) is trying to sue the county to get some money.”

Sheriff Lee said he sympathized with the family’s loss, but called allegations against his department out-

rageous. “Mr. Plunk died of an illness that had plagued him for years,” the sheriff said in a statement printed in Selmer’s weekly newspaper, The Independent-Appeal, “Neither myself or any members of the Sheriff's Department was involved in any beating or use of excessive foree regarding Mr. Plunk,”

Lawson, who lives in Selmer, called feed Lee's statement a “bunch of ies.”

Rosamond Tyler, the McNairy Hospital administrator, said the sheriff asked him not to release any information on.the ease, But Tyler confirmed that the sheriffs department requested an autopsy on Plunk,

Lawson said her brother was a disabled veteran who served in the Army and Air Force veteran who served during the Korean War, He was discharged after tuberculosis left him with the use of only one lung. The disability left him unable to work.

Plunk lived with his father until 1979, when he moved in with Lawson.

“(Plunk) was no problem whatsoever,” said Lawson, who cared for him

deputy then told Plunk to “shut up or we'll do it again,” Lawson said

Lawson said she told Sheriff Lee he “will get what is coming to him.”

‘(Sheriff Lee) said ‘I am the sheriff, no one will do anything to me,’” she said, “Then he laughed in my face.”

As hospital employees were preparing to take Plunk to Memphis, Lawson said she heard one of the officers. say “tie him so tight he can’t move.”

Sheriff Lee said the story Lawson gave was a “malicious lie.”

“If she does not cease making these unfounded lies, I’m going to file suit against her,” he said. “The only true statement she said was that I and a deputy were at the hospital.”

The hospital called the sheriff's department to help subdue a patient who allegedly struck a doctor and two nurses, Sheriff Lee said.

“I was not present at the hospital until whatever incident had occurred,” he said. “Plunk was placed in a bed by an officer of mine and one from the city.”

Sheriff Lee would not identify the two officers who restrained Plunk, but

for the past 13 years. Plunk’s health had worsened re-

cently because of emphysema, Lawson said.

After Plunk was taken July 29 to the MeNairy hospital, Lawson's and Sheriff.Lee’s stories about what.happened differ considerably.

Lawson said she left. Plunk at 2:30

.m,, and returned three hours later to

nd- Sheriff Lee anda deputy outside Plunk's private reom,

“When I walked into “room 183. (Plunk) was handcuffed .and his. face was beat up,” she said, “My brother said ‘please don’t leave me, They might even kill me.”

Plunk’s hands were allegedly handcuffed to the bed rails, his seat was tied down and his feet wrapped together with cloth and tied, she said. Sheriff Lee then entered and Lawson asked him who beat Plunk, she said.

“Sheriff Lee said ‘it ain’t none of your business, Get through that door or I'll handcuff you,’ * Lawson said.

Lawson then asked. Plunk who beat him and he identified the deputy present, she said. The sheriff and the

said no excessive force was used in handling Plunk.

“(Plunk) was secured to the bed with handcuffs,” Sheriff Lee said, adding Plunk was calm when Sheriff Lee arrived.

“TI went in after he was supposedly beaten. (Plunk) was talking and didn’t have a mark on him,” Sheriff Lee said. “There was no damage’ to. him other than being placed in the bed.”

Before. Sheriff Lee arrived, Plunk had been “extremely violent:. We didn’t know he was dying,” Sheriff Lee said.

“(Lawson).was ereating such a commotion, I asked her repeatedly to leave,” Sheriff Lee said, adding she vas interfering with efforts to restrain Plunk.

Sheriff Lee added Plunk had acted violently the night before he was hospitalized,

“Plunk had (family members) pinned in a room,” Sheriff Lee said. “When the deputies arrived, (Plunk)

said.Lawson beat him up and he want-

ed to take out a warrant on her.”

Back to the Sheriff Robert K. Lee gallery